Representing Clients in Trust, Estate, and Probate matters
Close this search box.

Contractual vs Testamentary Capacity

Understanding Testamentary Capacity Verses Contractual Capacity in California

California probate law holds many nuances. One critical area which holds unique but important distinctions in trust and estate litigation is the difference between the testamentary capacity (the capacity necessary to execute a will) and contractual capacity (the capacity to execute a contract).

Testamentary Capacity for Wills in California

Requirements for Testamentary Capacity in California

Probate Code Section 6100.5 codifies the standards for determining testamentary capacity. To establish testamentary capacity in California, an individual must typically:

  • Understand the Nature of the Act:
    Be aware that they are creating a will and comprehend its legal implications.
  • Know the Nature and Extent of Their Property:
    Have a reasonable understanding of their assets and their value.
  • Be Aware of Heirs and Beneficiaries:
    Recognize and comprehend the natural objects of their bounty, including family members and intended beneficiaries.
  • Comprehend the Disposition of Assets:
    Understand how their assets will be distributed and the impact of their decisions.

Capacity to Execute Contracts in California

Requirements for Capacity in Contract Law:

Probate Code Section 812 codifies the capacity standard applicable to contracts and legal decisions other than wills. In California, the capacity to execute a contract involves:

  • Age and Mental Competence:
    Parties must be of legal age (18 or older) and possess sufficient mental competence to understand the terms and obligations of the contract.
  • Understanding the Contract Terms:
    Individuals must understand the basic terms of the contract, including rights, responsibilities, and potential consequences.
  • Free Will and Voluntariness:
    Contracting parties must enter into the agreement voluntarily, without coercion or undue influence.

Distinctions between Testamentary Capacity and Contract Capacity

While both testamentary capacity for wills and contract capacity require a level of mental competence, they differ in their focus:

  • Will Capacity:
    Centers on the ability to understand and make decisions related to the distribution of one’s estate after death.
  • Contract Capacity:
    Focuses on the ability to comprehend and voluntarily enter into legally binding agreements.

Higher Degree of Capacity for Contracts

It is essential to recognize that contractual capacity often requires a higher degree of mental acuity than testamentary capacity. The reasoning behind this distinction lies in the nature of contractual relationships, which involve immediate and tangible consequences, financial obligations, and legal complexities.

Implications for Will Contests

When dealing with a will contest in California, individuals need to be aware that testamentary capacity is generally lower than the standard required for contractual capacity. Legal representation becomes crucial to parties seeking to understand the appropriate level of capacity required to execute or to challenge an instrument depending on whether the document is a will, or a contract.

How Estate Law California APC Can Help

If you have questions about capacity in wills or contracts, contact Estate Law California APC for a free telephone consultation.

Scroll to Top